Zoning appeals service experience and administrative operations
Year: 2022 / Role: Project lead, Senior Service Design Strategist / PHL Service Design Studio
CONTEXT
Philadelphia's Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA) hears roughly 1,500 cases per year making decisions on zoning variances, special exceptions, and permit decisions. ZBA hearings are quasi-judicial with independent board members and supporting administrative staff embedding in the Department of Planning and Development (DPD).
The process is complex, involving technical knowledge, legal requirements, administrative procedures, and multiple stakeholder groups. For everyday Philadelphians, navigating the process can be difficult and often requires legal representation or specialized knowledge. Zoning decisions have a direct impact on neighborhoods and communities, shaping what gets built, who can afford to stay, and whether residents have power to shape decisions impacting where they live.
The ZBA and DPD team partnered with the PHL Service Design Studio to holistically understand the service experience from a multi-stakeholder perspective and document their administrative operations with the goal of improving experiences for applicants and staff. The project was structured this way to allow the ZBA to make informed, evidence-based requests in the upcoming budget cycle.
CONTRIBUTIONS
Building a multi-stakeholder understanding
Led research to understand background and context of zoning, nuances of quasi-judicial operations and administrative procedures, and the human experience of people involved. Engaged 55 stakeholders across eight groups, including unrepresented applicants, attorneys, ZBA processing staff, Registered Community Organizations, Philadelphia Planning Commission staff, and City Council representatives.
Strengthening operational clarity
Worked closely with the ZBA administrator, supervisors, and attorney to document administrative processes, legal requirements, and unique scenarios. Translated operational insights into a series of process maps, roles of different groups, and administrative steps.
Selecting improvements that balance legal requirements
Collaborated with ZBA staff to make sense of challenges and identify improvements to process, information, tools, technology, and policy. Facilitated prioritization of recommendations based on ZBA's scope, operational purview, legislative requirements, and available resources and developed a roadmap for improvements.
SIGNIFICANCE
Process maps and project documentation were valuable deliverables that captured institutional knowledge primarily held by the ZBA administrator. These deliverables were used to hire and onboard several new employees and transfer operational know how.
The prioritized improvement roadmap helped the ZBA and DPD team to make specific budget requests, define who they need to collaborate or advocate with, and identify improvements that could be initiated with existing resources.
The project report served as documentation of the work indicating that ZBA was aware of issues with a plan forward and was shared across the larger department. It was also designed to be an advocacy tool capturing resident and community voice.
Team and credits: Project lead: Devika Menon, Project support: Veronica Yeung, Project oversight: Liana Dragoman